Board Game
Measurement | Score (1-5) |
Themes | 5 |
Kinesthetic | 5 |
layout | 4 |
Simplicity | 4 |
Total | 18 |
When rating the THEME I would say that with doing a 3-D board game, the possibilities are endless. I can literally let my imagination go wild and truly do something that the kids will enjoy learning from. I can possibly make a design where my intended players would be girls, so it would be a more girly theme in pinks an or pastels that way it would be more appealing to them and their attention has shifted from being bored and uninterested to suddenly becoming aware that the board game can actually be fun and without realizing it they will be learning THE DESIGN CYCLE. And the same goes for boys. If the theme is more like construction or army the color scheme will definitely make a difference. Which is why I scored it a 5.
My approach on this project will either make or break my success. I have decided that considering two completely different approaches will help me get a better understanding of what can work. Whether the kids are able to interact with the product is very important to me. I am the kind of person that learns by doing and seeing so therefor I am gonna create that something that I could use to easily learn something I am having trouble with.The fact that if people can touch it they are able to learn it better, makes me lean more towards wanting to do something that this kids can use to play with therefore I scored it a 5. I want the kids to interact and feel like they playing when actually the are learning.
The LAYOUT is something I definitely have to look into, and be very careful as to how I go about it. I want it to be simple yet very attractive and grab every one's attention. It need to be in a way that doesn't distract from the purpose of the actual game. I'm thinking something along the lines of Monopoly. The layout is very clear and somewhat simple. And besides the kids would be able to see the similarities and quickly get on board as to how to play it. The score I gave it was a 4 exactly because of that reason I believe that the layout could turn out to be very easy to understand.
If anything it would get a little complicated in the instructions, but overall the concept is very simple. which ties in with the theme and the layout. In the end the SIMPLICITY of the project comes down to all of the elements previously mentioned on my post. I want it to be something anyone can use at any time. That's why I went with the over all score of simplicity being a 4. It is not a five because I don't believe in something ever reaching the full potential completely, their will always be room for improvement and a little more to work on. But I believe that if I use the information I m planning on getting from the 6th graders then my final product will be great and very useful.
So in the end my FINAL SCORE for option #1, the board game, was of a score 18 out of 20. This score was almost perfect which leads me to believe that this will probably be the choice for my presentation. I think that with the scores being so high that this will be a better representation. But who know I still haven't rated the other one. I tried to get in the mindset of a 6th grader so I would score it accurately. Obviously this scores are totally up to me, I will have to work efficiently to make some changes in my design so that those 4's can eventually turn into 5's and it can be a successful product.
Something Online (Arcade Game)
Measurement | Sore (1-5) |
Themes | 3 |
Kinestethic | 0 |
layout | 3 |
Simplicity | 4 |
Total | 10 |
Since I did not actually look into an arcade website, my answers are probably not accurate, but I would think that the THEME are limited and not customisable. Which is why I decided to score it a 3.I would think that this might be interesting to SOME of the kids but not everyone. Some kids don't like playing games on the computer, I know I don't. I am gonna be honest and say that I feel like I am being bias but the reality of this is that I don't see myself actually trying to figure out how to find the perfect theme for all of the 6th graders on an arcade game online. I am not given many options and I can't go back a reprogram the way the website is ran.I want to have the power to say what I want to do and how I feel kids will learn, and that is not from a template that a website gives me.
The limitations of an arcade game online are obvious. This is something that you would need a computer and Internet to be able to use. I scored it a 0 in KINESTHETIC . I would like to see the students have something that they feel they can use regardless of the purpose of the actual game board, and with the arcade game although the theme helps it is not something they can hold in their hand and observe. My project has to be tangable something that they can PLAY with. This kids are still at an age were they like to mess around and I would think that they would rather mess around with a game board than with a computer because if something happens to the computer they would have to pay for it and that would get them introuble although that is not a valid argument since they probably don't care.... But anyways the score was given due to the fact that it doesnt make sense in my mind to give them something that I consider a waste of time and effort becouse I am not 100% sure that they will learn from it and I don't want to jepordize their learning.
Its hard to think of an extreme, SUPER hard LAYOUT out there for gaming in itself, so when I think of the layout of an online arcade game I can;t really say negative things. I think me scoring it a 3 is fair because I think that there are definitely some programs out there that have nice layouts that are children friendly. I could of scored it higher, like a 4, but the thing is that I would need to go in and actually see the websites of these arcade game and at this point I really can't go back. And again in these kinds of websites I can't make my own layout and on those in which there is an option to do so; adding to it is not an option you can only take away. And quite frankly I don't want to mess around with it, I like having the control and being able to do my own decisions specially with this project.
I scored it a 4 in SIMPLICITY. Even though I scored it kind of low in the rest I believe that it can be a simple website kids will easily understand. That doesn't necessarily mean that they will understand it, its just that they will know what to press to start playing. And that is not the idea for this project. They need to able to learn from playing, or so I believe but they need to be able to retain that information and later on apply it so that the show they have learned it. Even though they are able to understand they are not necessarily learning, and therefore the idea doesn't work. I know I'm probably being more than bias because I am sold on the conselt of the board game but I am trying to look at it as a researcher would; so I am over analying it.
So for my last scoring as the TOTAL, I added up all of the other components and it came up to a 10. Its half of 20 so its obviously something anyone could consider. I personally think that if I weren't doing the board game I would deffinitely be doing something along the lines of an online arcade game, but not right now. I want to do something that I feel comfortable working with and I fell like an program online limits my control and creativity and I can't worl very efficiently that way. So it has some work to do, again this is my opinion, I can't speak for anyone when I give my scores because everyone is different and they don't all learn the same way.